Monday, February 28, 2011

The Madness Before March

Warmup before the 2006 NCAA Men's Division I B...Image via Wikipedia The NCAA Tournament is coming up and while I am not the biggest fan of basketball I do enjoy March Madness. I don’t fully get the seeding though. I understand that you want to spread the talent around to all 4 brackets, but how do you decide the 1 and 2 seeds. You wouldn’t think it is complicated but the NCAA can’t make anything simple.

I was listening to SportsCenter today and heard a debate about who the 4 number 1 seeds were going to be and Duke wasn’t mentioned. I found that curious because Duke is currently ranked number 4 in the country. BYU was in as the 4th 1 seed on one projection and not included in the other. Once again this makes no sense. BYU is currently ranked 3rd and in both projections were outside the top 3 spots for the tournament. Texas, meanwhile, was the team that was being discussed as the only other possibility for a 1 seed. Texas is ranked 8th and just lost to CU after being ahead in that game by 22 points. How are they in the discussion?

Why is it a discussion in the first place? There is a ranking system in college basketball. Doesn’t it make sense that the top 4 seeds in the tournament should be the top 4 teams at the end of the season? Selection Sunday is meant to display all the teams that will go to the tournament. It’s not supposed to be a circus of who’s a 1 seed or a 2 seed. The only surprises should be in who are the final teams to make it or what bracket a team was placed in. What is the point of rankings if it doesn’t determine tournament seeding?
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Nuggets' Mistake

CHARLOTTE, NC - NOVEMBER 11:  Chauncey Billups...Image by Getty Images via @daylife I’m sure that everyone has heard by now that Carmello Anthony, Chauncy Billups, and 3 other Denver Nuggets were traded to the Knicks for 4 of their starters, 3 draft picks, and $3 million. For the past few days I’ve heard about how the Nuggets are doomed now that we lost Carmello. I’ve heard people talk about how Carmello will impact the Knicks, both positively and negatively. Why isn’t anyone talking about the player that actually matters in this deal, the X factor, Chauncy Billups?

Since coming into the league, Carmello has turned himself into one of the best scorers around. He’s averaging 25 points a game and has been known to get up into the mid 40’s at times. He is in the prime of his career but hasn’t won a thing. The biggest knock on Carmello is that he doesn’t play defense. This is absolutely true but I think that his biggest down fall is that he doesn’t make the players around him better. Carmello takes almost 2 times as many shots as Billups and well more than 2 times as many shots as any other member of the team while 11 of his teammates have a better shooting percentage. Carmello scores 23% of the points that the Nuggets average per game. That’s almost a quarter of the teams points. I heard yesterday on ESPN that he has the second most points off of isolation plays in the NBA, no team involvement after he gets the ball. He has just as many turnovers as assist while his defensive stats are far less than impressive (less than one steal and block per game). These stats are just for this season, but I ask you, where is he making the player around him better?

If you still don’t believe that Carmello hasn’t made anyone on the team better then just look at the post season success as your guide for who is more important. Without Billups in the lineup the Nuggets, led by Carmello, never made it out of the first round. In comes the veteran leadership of Billups, a man that won several NBA Championships, and suddenly the Nuggets make it to the Western Conference Finals and loose to the Lakers. Leadership in a locker room and on the court is far more important than being able to score less than 50% of the time. Billups’s arrival in Denver signified that. We lost Iverson in the trade to get Billups and even though Billups averaged fewer points per game, the team played better due to the leadership he provided.

I have no issue shipping Carmello off to any team, but the Nuggets threw in the only true leader that the team had. He was the only player with a championship and proven to be a clutch player. Who is going to lead the Nuggets on the court during this transition period? Lawson is only in his second year and doesn’t have the clout to be the guy. Afflalo is also very young but has a tremendous upside. Is he a team leader though? Nene has never stood out to me as being a vocal guy. Birdman and K-mart are more like grown children than leaders of men.

I know that getting rid of Carmello was a good idea. I feel as though he had done all that he could here in Denver and needed to go. To be honest, I wanted to keep Iverson and trade Carmello a few years ago. This particular trade was a disaster for Denver in the fact that now we have to start from scratch in the leadership department. I hope that in the off season the team will address that aspect directly and bring in a veteran guy with a proven track record that knows what it means to be on a team.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, February 17, 2011

The Plague That Haunts Us

Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver DeSean Jacks...Image via Wikipedia Today’s public schools are plagued by an old disease. People have been fighting this disease since the dawn of man. It is an illness that has led to more deaths than cancer, HIV, and the black plague combined. The disease is intolerance. Now, granted, in most school cases the death toll isn’t very high but just one death due to intolerance is unacceptable. That is why I want to bring as much attention to an article that my brother sent to me earlier this week as possible.

Rick Reilly of ESPN wrote an article, Eagles Over Wolves in a Rout. The article talks about a little boy, Nadin Khoury, who had been bullied by several students from his school in Philadelphia. When I say bullied I mean harassed, beaten, dragged along the ground, pushed into a tree, and hung on a fence while adults just watched. It wasn’t until one of the bullies posted the video of the beating on YouTube.com that Nadin’s mother was able to press charges. Nadin and his mother have since decided to take their story public in order to raise awareness. In doing so they caught the eye of the local paper, and then the national media grabbed hold of the story.

Nadin and his mother were invited to be on The View. While on the show Nadin was asked why he was making his story public knowledge. He responded with, "Next time maybe it could be somebody smaller than me. Maybe next time, somebody could really get hurt." This 13 year old boy knows that by telling his story he could be the victim of more abuse, but he tells his story so that maybe what happened to him won’t happen to anyone else. For showing such courage Nadin was surprised by his favorite athlete, DeSean Jackson of the Eagles. Jackson hugged the young boy and praised him for what he is doing. To hear what else Jackson has done for the boy read the article at http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=6120346 .

Not all bullying victims are beaten like Nadin was. In fact many are the victims of verbal, digital, and visual harassment. The old sticks and stones talk is meaningless to children that are the targets of bullies. Being called names at school is hurtful, but what makes it worse is the fact that even after school there is no escape these days. The internet has made it possible to torment someone at all hours of the day. Facebook and twitter allow people to write anything they want with no repercussions. Cells phones make people accessible wherever they go and thus easier to harass at all times of the day via text messages. Kids have taken these great new tools of society and turned them into a nightmare for others. The attacks through these mediums have gotten so bad that it has actually cost some kids their lives.

Why are kids like Nadin being bullied in the first place? The answer is simple, intolerance. People view differences as being weird and wrong. The reason I call intolerance a plague is because of how it spreads from person to person, from father to son, from mother to daughter. It is also treatable. We treat intolerance with education and acceptance. Different can seem weird and that is ok, but when we decide that different is wrong without understanding it then we see bullying.

Everyone needs to be like Nadin, and stand up to bullying. When you see someone treating another poor for no good reason don’t just stand idly by and allow it to continue. Stand up for those that are smaller than you and try to make sure that no one else is hurt due to bullying on your watch. DeSean Jackson is making his stand by starting a non-profit organization called DeSean Jackson Against Bullying. What will you do?

Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Shanahan Is a QB Killer

ASHBURN,VA - JANUARY 6:  Mike Shanahan, the ne...Image by Getty Images via @daylife Yesterday on my way to work I was listening to 104.3 The Fan here in the Denver metro area. The show was talking about how Mike Shanahan handled Jake Plummer after the disastrous AFC Championship. The question was raised due to Peter Forsberg’s having to retire due to a chronic foot ailment. The show was discussing the difference between leaving a sport on your own terms and leaving due to injury. I don’t know if Plummer was supposed to be the example of leaving on his own terms, but it sounded that way from what I heard. That’s funny because Plummer was run out of the league by his coach, Mike Shanahan.

Plummer went 13-3 in 2005 and took the Broncos to the AFC Championship game. The second quarter of the championship game didn’t go as planned and the Broncos went into halftime down 21-3 to the eventual Super Bowl Champions Steelers. Mid way through the second quarter, the Broncos threw out their game plan because they fell behind and panicked. Instead of running the ball and using the play action passing game the Broncos dropped back and passed more than they ran. After the loss, Shanahan never stood up for his QB or took any responsibility for the loss. Instead he drafted Jay Cutler in the first round and never committed to Plummer for the 2006 season. This action finished Plummer’s career.

In 2005 Plummer was affectionately known as “No Mistake Jake.” The Broncos ran 54% of the time during the 2005 season and allowed Plummer to use the play action passing game. He had one of his best seasons and was repaid, by his coach, with taking all the blame for losing a game in which the Bronco’s threw 59% of the time. He was blamed for losing a game in which the Broncos ran the ball for an average of 4.9 yards a carry, but didn’t run the ball after mid way through the second quarter. He is blamed for performing how he has always performed when asked to throw that much. Shanahan made the call to stop running the ball, he panicked; he failed by asking his QB to do something that he had proven he couldn’t do very well. That all falls on the coach, not the player.

In 2006 Plummer led the Broncos to 7-4 with a good chance at making the postseason again and was repaid for this by being benched. Jay Cutler finished the season, the Broncos didn’t make the playoffs, and Plummer never took another snap in the NFL. If Shanahan would have stood by his game plan in the AFC Championship they could have won a Super Bowl that year. If he had stood by his QB after that game and during the 2006 season the Broncos could have won the Super Bowl that year as well. Chicago went to the Super Bowl that year with Rex Grossman. At one point during the season Rex had a QB rating of 0, 0! Do you know what his head coach said after that game? “Rex is our quarterback.” Plummer never had a QB rating of 0 and he never received that kind of loyalty or support from his coach.

If you still don’t believe me about Shanahan being a QB killer then look at what he did with Donavan McNabb. McNabb had been with the Eagles for 10 years, made the playoffs most years, 4 NFC Championship games (1 title), 1 Super Bowl appearance, and thought by many to be future Hall of Famer. One year in with Shanahan and his judgment, work ethic, and stamina were all brought into question. He was replaced by Rex Grossman with several games left in the season and told that he may not be back next season. Oh yeah, this was all done in public. Does anyone know how hard it is to go from an offense that you have run your entire career to a new coach, scheme, and terminology? Ask Brett Farve when he went to the Jets. It takes time to learn it all and be comfortable enough to be proficient. Instead of giving McNabb, possible Hall of Famer, the time needed to adjust and thrive he was shown the door and thrown under a bus.

I haven’t respected Shanahan since the Plummer incident and so far in Washington he looks like the same back stabbing guy. I don’t know how anyone can trust him enough to play for him. I hope Rex finds another job because if his career isn’t over yet then it will be after another bad year for Shanahan. You know he won’t take the blame.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, February 4, 2011

Super Bowl Prediction

The San Francisco 49ers' Super Bowl XXIX troph...Image via Wikipedia The Super Bowl is probably America’s favorite event of the year. I treat it like a holiday and I think others do as well. Two weeks of anticipation comes down to an hour of game play. Two teams play for bragging rights, the Lombardi Trophy, and their coveted rings. Commentators have been predicting who would be in the game and who would win it for the last 6 months. Why should I be any different?

I believe that the Green Bay Packers will win Super Bowl XLV. The key matchup that I think the packers can and need to exploit is their receivers against the Steelers secondary. Neither team is going to be able to run the ball very effectively so the passing game is going to decide the game. The packers have a better secondary overall and Charles Woodsen is the equalizer to Troy Polamalu. If Aaron Rodgers can protect the ball and keep Polamalu from making a notable impact on the game then I feel the Packer receivers can make enough plays against the Steelers’ corners to win the game.

I see the game going much like the NFC Championship game. Green Bay will be able to take advantage of some quick hitting plays and score first. The Steelers will settle in and slow the offensive attack for the Packers down. The Steelers will be able to score a few times during the game but not with any consistency. Green Bay matches scores with the Steelers after the open one or 2 scores and eventually wins the game. The Packers will win by either 7 or 10 points.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Since When is Replaceable Elite?

Ben Roethlisberger of the Pittsbrgh Steelers d...Image via Wikipedia Top Ten QB’s :
1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Phillip Rivers
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Eli Manning
7. Ben Roethlisberger
8. Matt Ryan
9. Tony Romo
10. Joe Flacco

Criteria: When making this list I didn’t look at a single stat. This list is based a combination of overall skills, responsibilities, leadership qualities, and team performance without them (predicted in many cases). I made this list because all week people are talking about Roethlisberger, of the Pittsburgh Steelers, being a historically elite QB by winning his third ring. Not only is he not elite historically, he isn’t elite in the league right now. Winning Super Bowls can’t be the only criteria for being elite. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl. Is he a better QB than Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, or even a Donavan McNab? Doubtful, though he was a solid QB.

Ben is also a solid QB, but how can you be elite when your team can win without you? Ben didn’t play for the first 4 games this year and his team won all but one and that game was decided in the final minutes of the 4th quarter. Not only did his team win with a backup, but they also won with a fourth string QB. That’s right; they won with a guy that wasn’t even supposed to be on the roster. I know it is unfair to Ben that his running game and defense are so good, but imagine what the top 3 guys on the list could do with just one of those qualities on their teams.

The only thing that Ben does at an elite level is avoid being sacked. He is very hard to bring down. Some would say that his ability to extend the play is elite, but I don’t see it. Gaining an extra second to allow a route to develop is elite. Running around, waiting for receivers to break off their routes and eventually get open is something most kids do at the local playground. If it were an occasional thing that he did when the situation warranted it then I would feel differently about it, but it appears that he will actually extend plays that don’t need to be extended. Giving up throwing the ball to open short receivers in order to push the ball down field is not good football. I don’t care how often it works out for him; it is a style of play that can’t be trusted.

There are 3 elite QB’s in the league and they don’t rely on the big extended play. They rely on processing information before and after the ball is snapped and making a decision within 3 seconds of the ball getting in their hands. Reading defenses quickly and releasing the ball on time and accurately are what make QB’s elite. That isn’t what Ben does best. Elite QB’s have a great deal of input on the offense as well. Peyton calls the plays, Tom coaches up everyone on that team during the game and on the sideline, and Drew helped develop the offense in New Orleans. You don’t hear about Ben doing any of that.

Ben is a very good QB. Very good is not elite and I think these days we are willing to settle for less because we are in the times of, “everyone’s a winner”. Ben won one Super Bowl despite his terrible play when he was a rookie. He won the last one because the defense for the other team was awful. The Steelers’ defense has been elite for some time and he has been able to rely on the running game for most of his career. That team would be in the playoffs without him and possibly in the Super Bowl. In my mind, if there is that kind of doubt to your impact on the outcome of a team’s season then you aren’t elite.
Enhanced by Zemanta