Monday, January 31, 2011

College Players Aren't Paid?

Tichenor Hall, Auburn University, Auburn, Alab...Image via Wikipedia Today I was watching a great college sports movie, Blue Chips. The movie tells a story about how money has corrupted the world of college basketball and college athletics in general. It ask the question, is it ok to pay college athletes for what they do for the school? The movie depicts a coach that would answer that question with a firm no until he is faced with a few bad years and great desire to win. The boosters say yes because they want their team to win and the school, as well as themselves, to make money. Why has no one pointed out the obvious? The players that people want to pay are already being paid by the universities.

I’m not crazy and I’m not stupid, I just feel that tuition along with room and board count. The major players in all the sports played at the collegiate level receive full rides to the universities that they decide to play for. That covers every expense that the school would get from any other student including tuition, fees, a room to stay in, up to a full meal plan, and the price of books. I reviewed the cost of attending the last 6 BCS National Champions and found that this is not a small stipend. It cost a resident of Georgia $23,486 to attend Auburn University and $37,502 for non- residents. The lowest cost for a resident student at one of these universities was $10,412 for the University of Alabama. The highest cost was for USC, $53,618 per year and that didn’t specify if it was the resident or non-resident rate. That means that, for a typical 4 year degree plan, a full ride athlete gets anywhere from $41,648 to $214,472 to play a game. How is that not enough?

I have heard about the universities making millions off of these athletes and the athletes get nothing. A top quality education shouldn’t be considered nothing, especially since not all scholarship athletes will make the professional ranks in their sport. Thanks to what the universities are doing for them these athletes will have options that they might not have had otherwise. Besides, it’s not like only one athlete gets a scholarship per year at these universities. Every sport has multiple scholarships to give every year so the university has well over 100 scholarships being honored per year potentially costing the university millions of dollars.

I have also heard about how some of these athletes’ families are so poor that they can’t afford to go out and enjoy the college experience. These students have to spend so much time practicing and studying that they don’t have time to work a part time job to earn spending money. Ok, I can see that, but every campus in this country has entertainment brought right to them. Movies are shown on campus, comedians tour campuses, theater and music programs perform, well known bands will tour to campuses. All major universities have rec. centers as well as student lounges filled with TV’s, pool tables, video games and more. If your parents can’t afford to give you a little spending money then so be it. The university doesn’t owe you anymore than it already provides.

Buying talent is college athletics is wrong. The scholarship programs are more than enough payment for any athlete. The student athlete is much better off for what they get out of the deal then the universities. The universities get you for 4 years and whatever revenue that you may generate with your play for that 4 year term. You don’t have to pay for a college education that can potentially carry you for the rest of your life whether you go pro in your sport or not. The advantage goes to the student athlete.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

18 Games is Not a Fan Favorite

National Football League commissioner Roger Go...Image via Wikipedia I was watching Jim Rome Is Burning today and listened to him talk about the impending lockout in the NFL. Rome was talking about how Antonio Cromartie might be the voice of reason among all involved in the negotiation which isn’t what I’m going to talk about. During that burn I heard about how the players won’t play an 18 game schedule and that the commissioner, Roger Goodell said that the owners and fans all want to see it happen. Really… the fans want a longer season?

I don’t know who Commissioner Goodell is talking to, but I haven’t heard any fans talking about how great a longer season would be. Personally, I think it is a terrible idea. By extending the season by an additional 2 games what is going to happen? The players are going to be exposed to more injuries, teams that are doing poorly will continue to struggle to fill seats and the fans of that team will be punished by blackouts. More late season games will be reduced to the equivalent of preseason games with elite players being benched for rest before the playoffs. I don’t see how any of this helps the league grow its fan base or its product.

The players are afraid of be subjected to more injuries during a longer regular season and well they should be. It seems like every day we are finding out more and more about the long term effects of playing in the NFL. Adding 2 games to the season is only going to increase the number of injuries suffered in a season. This has the possibility of shortening careers drastically, plus ruin the quality of life of some of these athletes after their careers. Most of which don’t make the ridiculous money that the top players do, but sacrifice just as much. The fans are worried about these injuries as well. Who wants to pay to go see a team of backups? I don’t. I don’t even want to pay the insane prices for the starters. More injuries will equal a lesser product and nobody wants that.

As the rules are now, if a stadium doesn’t sell out then the game will be blocked out in the city in which it is played. I already hate this rule and now it will be an even bigger problem. Fans of lousy teams won’t pay to see them at the stadium so no one will be able to see that team in that city outside of the stadium. How is that supposed to grow a fan base? I understand that the owners want full stadiums, but in order to fill those stadiums you need a good product to put on the field and not every team is good every year. Why punish the fans for the management’s inability to put together a respectable team? It makes no sense and the problem will only get worse with a longer season.

Every year for the last few games of the season the question of resting players is always brought up. The teams that run away with their divisions have the opportunity to sit players for games that have no meaning for them and they have earned the right to do so even though I believe it goes against the basic principles of all sports. There will be instances where teams will clinch divisions and playoff spots with 4 or more games to play. What will happen then? That teams remaining games will look like preseason games because the starters will only play for a half. Why risk hurting your star players in games that don’t mean anything to your club? The price of a ticket will be the same and once again the fan gets cheated out of a quality product.

I think that the commissioner has his facts a little twisted. The fans don’t want and aren’t calling for a longer season. We want a better product in the preseason along with cheaper tickets for the preseason. Why should I have to pay a regular season price to watch a game that is full of third stringers and guys who won’t even be on the team during the regular season? If you want to eliminate a few preseason games then so be it but we want a great product and a longer season doesn’t promise that. Now with that said, we will watch a longer season even if we don’t want it because we love football.

Don’t use the fans as a bargaining chip to manipulate the situation. This is about money and specifically who gets more of it. We pay the outrageous ticket prices. We pay the overly inflated prices for our favorite player’s jersey. We pay for the Sunday NFL Ticket so that we can watch our favorite teams all year round. If this had anything to do with the fans then there wouldn’t be any chance of a lockout, blackouts wouldn’t exist and ticket prices would be affordable for people like me. The fans want football, once you figure out the money issues let us know so that we can get back to what we want.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Sunday, January 16, 2011

The Broncos Get a Fox

ENGLEWOOD, CO - JANUARY 14:  Denver Broncos he...Image by Getty Images via @daylife I have listened all week to people like Drew Soicher of 9News here in Denver mock the Broncos recent hire of John Fox. I can’t stand any of the local sports anchors here in Denver, but Mr. Soicher asked a really good question the other night that, unlike him, I will answer with facts rather than perception. Is John Fox the best that the Broncos could do? Really? The answer is yes and if Mr. Soicher new anything about football or sports in general then he would know that.

Let’s look at the body of work. Fox has been coaching football for more than 30 years. That is a great deal of experience being brought to the Denver Broncos organization. He has been to at least 2 Super Bowls, one as the defensive coordinator for the NY Giants and once as the head coach of the Carolina Panthers. As a head coach he has won more than he has lost, won 3 division titles making the playoffs as the number one seed in the NFC once, won an NFC Championship, and was respected by his players even after a terrible final year.

Mr. Soicher and many others want to focus on just the last year that Fox had Carolina instead of focusing on the larger picture of his 9 year career there. So, let’s look at the big picture. As the head coach in Carolina, Fox never had an elite quarterback. In fact, he never had a quarterback that was much better than average. In a season where Jake Delhomme played 11 games or more he never had a passer rating better than 88.1. In his 7 seasons with the Panthers he threw 122 TD’s and 96 Int’s. As you can see there is nothing impressive about any of these stats. In 2009 Matt Moore stepped in for Delhomme for a few games and since Moore’s QB rating was 40 plus points higher than Delhomme’s, the team thought that keeping Moore and dealing Delhomme would be best for the team. Moore played 6 games with a rating of 55.6 while throwing twice as many Int’s as TD’s. In steps Jimmy Clausen from Notre Dame. He plays 12 games with a rating of 58.4 while throwing 3 times as many Int’s as TD’s. Not much of a passing game in Carolina for the 9 years Fox was there.

Now we have to look at how the passing game affects the rushing game. Fox has always loved to run the ball. As a defensive coordinator he has always been aware of the fact that a team that can run is always dangerous. He took that mentality to the Panthers and established a solid running game. When the passing game was ok then the team was winning looked pretty good. When the passing game is bad then the running game suffers because the defense only has to worry about that one aspect of the game. Play action passing is only affective if you have the personnel to make it work and when defenses are still afraid of you passing in general. Otherwise you are running your play fake into a consistent blitz package that has the potential to kill your play. So, when you look at the fact that the passing game was never anything to really fear, only being ranked in the top half of the league twice in Fox’s nine years, it is pretty impressive that the team made the playoffs 3 times.

The Broncos have had not had a problem scoring points over the years. Their biggest problem has been the fact that they just can’t score enough points due to the defense being one of the worst in the league. The linebackers are terrible, the defensive line is average and the defensive backfield is just below average as a whole, Champ Bailey being the lone standout. John fox has spent his entire career on the defensive side of the ball. The defense in Carolina since he has been there has been very good. This year the defense got run down because the offense couldn’t give them a break. Fox will improve the defense here in Denver, but it is up to Elway and the General Manager to improve the talent level, especially at the linebacker position.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Another Raider Mistake

KANSAS CITY, MO - SEPTEMBER 20:  Head coach To...Image by Getty Images via @daylife This morning the head coach for the Oakland Raiders, Tom Cable, was let go. Al Davis had decided not to pick up the 2 year, 5 million dollar option on Cables contract. As head coach of the Raiders cable went 17-27 with no trips to the post season. At first site these numbers do appear to be enough of a reason to fire Cable but I will show you why this could be one of the worst decisions Al Davis has made in a long time.

Tom cable took over the head coaching job for the Raiders after Lane Kiffen had been fired for not playing Jamarcus Russell. The team was terrible and if cable wanted to keep his job he was going to have to play the young, out of shape, and flat out bad QB that Al wanted. As a starter during the 2008- 2009 seasons, Russell had 16 TD’s and 19 interceptions. He fumbles 21 times and lost 13 of those fumbles. His best rating during that span was 77.1 which is nothing to brag about. Including his 1 TD run in 2008, Russell was responsible for 32 turnovers to 17 TD’s in 27 games. So, Cable’s hands were kind of tied for a good part of his first full season as head coach.

In that first full season Cable was able to win only 5 games. 11 losses in a season is pretty bad but if we break down the season a little further we can see that in this case it isn’t terrible. Of the 5 wins that the Raiders had that season, 3 of them were against playoff teams. Also, 5 of the 11 losses were by only one score. This means that the Raiders were in or winning 10 out of the 16 games that they played that year. This is encouraging as long as loosing the close games doesn’t continue to be a problem in future seasons.

In the second full season of Cables head coaching stint he was able to get a professional and talented QB in Jason Campbell. Campbell didn’t pick up the offense as quickly as the Raiders would have liked and due to this the team got off to a rocky start and Campbell was benched for a short while. Things would improve and the Raiders finished this season at 8-8. Once again this is not a season to brag about until we dig a little deeper. There were 4 games that the Raiders lost by one score. So this means that they were in or won 12 of the 16 games that they played this season. 6 of the 8 wins the team had came against the AFC West, the Raiders division. That’s right; they swept their division and didn’t make the playoffs. Not only did they sweep the division but they flat out dominated it 215 points for to 107 points against. They doubled up the division in points.

In 2 full seasons Tom Cable went 13-19 and never made the playoffs. So, why keep him around and pick up the 5 million dollar option in his contract? The answer is simple; the Raiders franchise is no longer a joke. Cable broke down the team last off season and made every single player focus on the basics because he saw that the whole team couldn’t play the right way. He focused on fundamentals and physicality. In his first season as the head coach the team made a point to let others know that they were going to get hit. The Raiders were no joke on defense but the turnovers on offense were killing them. This season was much of the same except they didn’t turn the ball over as much and managed to win 3 more games than last season. The team was competitive and for the first time in a long time didn’t appear to be a living soap opera.

It takes time to turn an organization like the Raiders around and Cable was definitely on the right track. He had the team getting better and winning games, especially in the division. Given the stability of 2 more years under the same guy it could only lead to bigger and better things. Now Al Davis has to start over with new coaches, a new system, and more than likely a lot of new players since the ones he has now are not at all happy about the owner’s decision. Several players have expressed concern about the decision and made comments about many of the free agents probably looking for another place to play next year.

Mr. Davis, get out of your own way and let someone else make the football decisions. You are screwing up your team more than anything else. Thanks to you, and you alone, the team will take more steps backwards instead of finally taking a few steps forward. Look forward to more losing seasons with no good coaching prospects willing to work for you. Who could possibly want a job where even if you do well you get fired?
Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, January 3, 2011

An NFL Season to Remember

MINNEAPOLIS - JANUARY 17:  (L-R) Wide receiver...Image by Getty Images via @daylife Anyone that loves football and loves the NFL knows that this year was as strange a year as we may ever see. Records were broken and extended, expectations were met, surpassed and sometimes not even close to lived up too. Every week there was a new story that blew everyone's mind. I can't wait to talk about this.

Let's start with the return of Brett Farve. He returned for his 20 season so that he could play with his teammates in Minnesota one last time. He was hoping to repeat the success that he had the previous year and possibly lead his team to a Super Bowl. He was missing his most important weapon in Sydney Rice for most of the season, the offensive line was terrible and the Receivers he had tipped some balls that turned into turnovers. He fell way short of his goals for the season but still managed to hit some incredible milestones. He has now thrown for over 500 TD's in his career and played in 297 straight games. I don't think either of these numbers will ever be seen again and there will never be a single player that I would like to watch more than Brett. Enjoy retirement, you earned it.

Randy Moss has played 3 different team in this one season. A man that was rejuvenated in New England wound up playing for the Vikings and Titans. He wanted to stay in New England but after the first game he made some comments about how there were people that didn't want that to happen and I guess he was right since they shipped him out a few weeks later. He spent a few weeks with the Vikings before he alienated his coaching staff, a few players and a buffet chef. He wound up with the Titans and honestly I haven't really of heard of him since. One of the leagues best deep threats and he couldn't find a team to use him properly. Maybe next year Randy.

There were 4 coaches fired in the middle of the season. I don't think that I have ever seen that before and I hope I never see it again. The Cowboys fire Wade Phillips for his teams gross underachievements. They had dreams of a home game in the Super Bowl and manage to finish outside of the playoffs midway through the season. Brad Childress was fired for the same reason plus some shotty personnel decisions. He begged Bret Farve to return, brought in Randy Moss to open up the field, questioned Percy Harvin's toughness and released Randy without the consent of the owner. Not really sure what he was thinking about that last part. Josh McDaniels embarrassed the Broncos franchise with spygate 2 and couldn't win to save his job. Mike Singletary was released from the 49ers with just one game to play because he didn't live up to the expectations and he couldn't choose one or get along with his QB's. I like Mike and hope to see him coaching again.

For the first time in my lifetime a team beat every team in their division twice and didn't win their division or even make the playoffs. The Oakland Raiders dominated the AFC West this year but couldn't win more than 2 games outside the division. They finish the season 8-8 and out the playoffs.

On a similar note, the Seattle Seahawks didn't even win half of their games and wound up winning their division. This NFC West division is the worst in football. Not one team had a wining record but yet they get to host a playoff game. The Giants go 10-6, 3 games better than the Seahawks, and have to watch the playoffs this year, along with several other teams with above 500 records. I wish that the rules for making the playoffs would change but since this type of thing doesn't happen very often it is highly unlikely anything will change. Here is to hoping that next years Toilet Bowl doesn't decide a playoff spot.

I am sure that there are several things that I left out that fit the strange feel of this season, but that doesn't change the fact that this is still one of the most interesting seasons in league history. I hope that I get to talk about more strange goings on next season instead of making references to past seasons due to a lock out. Football has a great following and has the potential for great stories as we have seen this year, but I fear what could happen to this game if we can't watch it for a season.

Enhanced by Zemanta